Saturday, July 14, 2007
Determining the Communicative Intent
I'm rapidly learning to never discuss Slugger's issues or needs with non-adoptive parents. In fact, I'm even learning that people who haven't adopted older kids just don't get it. Other than a few rare exceptions (as in my bestest, bestest friend who always manages to "get it") the people I lean on and confide in is becoming smaller. I am incredibly lucky, however, in that I have a large and diverse group of friends that have adopted older children (or have hosted older children and went on to adopt babies or toddlers).

The reason I'm remaining close-mouthed is that many behaviors that are typical for kids like Slugger sound, well, typical. It's part of the reason I've had trouble posting. For example, writing about how Slugger constantly asks me and everyone else to buy/give him things doesn't truly describe the situation. Almost all kids go through a gimme-gimme stage at some point. For some kids it never really goes away. But Slugger's behavior isn't typical. There's a desperation and a test for affection behind every request -- you can see it in his eyes. Maybe the action is typical, but the intent is far, far from typical.

As many of you probably do, I frequent many adoption and post-adoption parenting blogs. I often read posts describing (or venting about) PI behaviors and other issues that most likely are the result of a child's background. More often than not there are a handful of well-intentioned people who leave comments that, I'm sure, are meant to be reassuring. Comments along the lines of "that's typical" or "that's normal" or "all kids do that." For me, those kind reassurances fall flat. They are nails on a chalkboard to me. My son's behaviors are incredibly atypical, abnormal, and very-unlike-other-kids. The problem is these atypical behaviors mask themselves as typical ones.

A while back I left a comment on someone else's blog. She had posted about some difficult issues and almost all of the comments people left were of the sweet, but misguided, "Don't worry... my two-year-old does that, too" variety. I left a comment that went something like this:

"Let's say you have two seven-year-old boys. One is running down the street for the sheer joy of it -- letting the wind run through his hair and having fun. The other is running down the street is sheer terror because a bad man is chasing him. The boys are both running; they're exhibiting exactly the same behavior. The reasons for the behavior, however, are vastly different. Also the emotion and intensity of the behavior is drastically different."

What I was trying to describe is what professionals call "communicative intent." The phrase is often used to describe behaviors in children or adolescents with autism spectrum disorders, global development delays, even ADHD. It is also very appropriate for some children who have suffered prolonged neglect, abuse, multiple moves, prenatal exposure, or orphanage life.

Children are often unable to verbalize their feelings. That level of self-analysis is too hard for young kids. So, their feelings are often displayed through behavior or acting out. It is up to parents to determine the communicative intent of the behavior -- what emotion or issue is causing the child to behave that way? What are they trying to express? While many behaviors that post-foster or post-institutionalized kids display may seem typical in some ways, the communicative intent is (often) entirely different. These kids have a different range of experiences than children who spent their first years in a loving, consistent environment.

For a child like Slugger, who spent TEN years without a loving, consistent environment, the issues are exacerbated to the nth degree.

It is a constant struggle trying to figure out the root cause of behaviors. Especially when you have a child like Slugger, who has lived with eight different families before me, has experienced severe deprivation and neglect, has endured horrendous abuse that would bring adults quivering to their knees, was prenatally exposed to alcohol and possibly drugs, has multiple confirmed diagnoses (and several possible diagnoses), and has been removed from his birth family and later abandoned by an adoptive family. Analyzing his behaviors is like trying to put together a 1000-piece puzzle that's all one color. His behaviors could be the result of any one or combination of his issues, but to really help him, I've got to find just the right puzzle piece. I also have to be careful not to over-analyze his behaviors, to take him out from under the parenting microscope, and to just let him be a kid a times. Finding the balance is very hard, indeed.

With Slugger, it's also hard to anticipate his reactions. Slugger is 10, but he generally functions on a 7- or 8-year-old level emotionally. However, he sometimes processes emotions on a 3-year-old level. In other ways, Slugger is far advanced in years. He has some behaviors that are more like a 16-year-old; he certainly has knowledge far beyond his years. He runs the gamut emotionally, and it's very difficult for me to predict his reactions when his emotional barometer is so volatile. Cognitively, Slugger is at or just below grade level. But emotionally, he is undoubtedly delayed.

I understand all of these issues. I signed up for this job and even though it is much more tiring that I anticipated, I'm not surprised in the tiniest bit. There are times when it's not fun, there are times I wish I could just escape for a few minutes... but I asked for this. I want this. I know that the frustrating behaviors do not make my child. Some of them are organic -- caused by prenatal exposure. These will never go away. My role is to accept who he is, understand his limitations, and help him learn to manage those areas of difficulty. Other behaviors are due to neglect, mistreatment, or instability. These can be modified, if not fully corrected, in time. It is my job to figure out the roots of his behaviors, help break through them, and teach him to understand and trust again. But he is not his behaviors. Slugger is a bright and happy child with a killer sense of humor and an indefatigable spirit. He's clever and determined and sometimes sweet. He's skilled at building and puzzles and has a memory that never quits. He's incredibly athletic and coordinated. He's bold and inquisitive. Above all, he wants to be loved and to love in return. But he's so riddled with defenses, insecurities, issues, behaviors, and problems, his wonderful traits are virtually buried. It's like panning for gold -- through the mud and the grit and the mucky water I get an occasional glimpse of something that sparkles and shines.

Slugger's behaviors may sound like any other kids, but they are more frequent, more intense, more concentrated, and more complex. Slugger is not typical. He's not like other kids...

... he's spectacular.

Labels:

32 Comments:
Blogger Jenny and Matt said...
Margaret,
I check your blog daily and am always excited to see a new post. I have no experience with what you and Slugger are going through as my daughter came home at 8 months old and we've yet to see how her past will affect her. I don't often comment on your blog because I usually feel like I have nothing to contribute, I am usually so moved by your story that I can't really articulate well enough any kind of encouragement or offer advice.
I just want today to say that I am so impressed by your dedication, your stamina, and your love for Slugger. Even before you knew him you seem to have done all you could to prepare yourself to be a parent.
As an adoptive Mom I know we will have our "issues" ahead of us. We are currently considering an older child adoption and are working hard to prepare ourselves for all that entails. I just feel so appreciative, and motivated when I read your blog. No, this isn't easy, but you let us know just how worth it the tough times can be.

Blogger Jo said...
Well, yes, that actually sounds very similar to what I am dealing with. I mean, sharing with those who don't get it. And I know sometimes being firm with my kid looks too firm to others. It has actually become a blessing in some ways that he no longer looks or behaves normally, people automatically give us some berth, both emotionally and physically. Even though Little Man came into our lives as an infant, his ODD makes him behave in some very difficult ways. There are some things I get about your journey because they seem very similar to mine, and the things I don't I give you all the benefit of the doubt. You are doing great, from my vantage point.
BTW, as a long time foster parent, I have found it is much much easier to be very firm in the beginning to establish bounderies and authority and then ease up if it looks like you can.
Spoiling the new kid in the honeymoon ends up being such a disaster. And it took me a whole bunch of foster kids to learn that, you are much wiser than I was.

Blogger Roy and Lori said...
Best of luck to you and slugger!
It is great that he has such
a special mom like you!

Blogger Her Grace said...
Great post and great explanation. You're absolutely right, sometimes behaviors of kids like Slugger DO sound typical, but a sensitive parent recognizes that they are very much not normal.

I'm so glad you're finding those nuggets of joy underneath it all. I know you're tired and I hope those small moments keep you going.

Blogger Rachael said...
Determining the communicative intent: you hit the nail on the head with that one. It is very challenging to sort out the core of behaviors in some adopted children (esp. older). You seem to have a real knack for it though. I'm sometimes fearful of overanalyzing behaviors and want to err on the side of seeing the normalcy in many things, but also don't want to miss the chance to get to the core of problem too. It's a fine line to balance and definately keeps you on your parenting A-game. I know what you mean about others not being able to really understand. You really can't until you are living it.

Blogger Rachael said...
Oh, and also, Katya did the "buy me this", "more, more" etc. thing too. It surprised me so much how quickly she could go from having nothing to wanting everything, and never seeming grateful for all that she now had. You, know, it has really improved and lessened though in just a short time. I think she's realizing that it's love she craves, not just things, and as she lets us in and lets us give her love, she doesn't ask so much for things anymore. Well, she'll still often ask, but now when I say no, she doesn't get upset and takes it in stride, so we're making progress. I can't even describe to you the fear I had of taking that child into a store during that first month home (not pretty a few times), but, well, I think you might have some inkling.

Blogger Jules/TX said...
I honestly don't have a clue as to what you are both going through. I have my own clues with our adopted son... but those are his and ours. Maybe ours is an orange puzzle?

I keep you and A in my prayers daily. It's the one thing I can do that I feel will make a difference.

Hugs.........

Blogger Yondalla said...
I do love your posts.

You work so hard at understanding the children and express what it so well.

What you wrote reminded me of the princess behavior I was trying to describe before. Something can look normal when you don't see how intense it is.

Take care of yourself.

I'm shaking my head over and over reading your words. It is SO frustrating to hear from EVERY friend and family I have that my son is just, "being a boy" or he's just, "extremely stubborn" or he is, "just going through a toddler thing." NO! He isn't. He is different from other kids beacuse of his very painful past. He doesn't trust he'll be taken care of and that is why he INSISTS on doing everything for himself and being in control, always. Yes, I get that toddlers test and I get that some kids like to be in control and do thinghs for themselves to gain that indeendence, but NO! he isn't those kids. I think people mean well, but it sure would be nice if someone understood. Thank you for your post. I KNOW you understand.

Anonymous Anonymous said...
What a loving, perceptive, sensitive and intelligent post.

Blogger Esther said...
Maggie-

This post is either my favorite or one of my favorites that you have written so far. I whole heartedly agree, appreciate, and support what you've said.

You've certainly hit the nail on the head here in defining that you as a parent are trying to see what's behind the behavior, and it's not the behavior that makes the child. Good for you!

I've never made a public statement myself about people making the trite "oh I know", "my kid does that too", "that happens all the time", etc., comments. Sometimes I feel those comments are false and/or uneducated. I think people are attempting to be supportive, perhaps they assume to know what others are going thru by projecting, maybe it's all they know to say.....
People want to be kind, so they say what comes to mind and attempt to be supportive and helpful. So when I hear stuff like that, I just appreciate it for the heartfelt attempt at a loving effort.

But adopting an older child, and I mean school age child older, means that these kids have gone thru the most serious trauma, grief, loss, tragedy, abuse, yada yada yada, to be in the system and adopted at that older age. These kids have really been thru the ringer. I realize younger kids have as well. However, the older kids have done it LONGER! I can't even imagine. Well, in a way I can as I was raised in an abusive, alcoholic, neglected home, but that's another talk show.

You are wise to not engage with you parents, family, and anyone who is taking too much energy out of you in discussing Slugger. I've taken this approach myself. It's been most difficult with my Mom. I've really had to distance her. She's just not educated enough here to get it and she doesn't have emotional where-with-all. Uh, not to mention the fact that she raised me in that abusive, alcoholic, neglected household? I feel she has no judgement skills, perception, or wisdom to offer up in the adoption category (or parenting to boot), so I rarely speak of it with her. Works best that way.

Keep following your instincts. They are speaking wisdom to you.

Hugs, Esther

Blogger Jeff and Michelle said...
I could picture you presenting this as a speech to adoptive parents somewhere! I wish I would have had this to share with family members and friends four years ago when we were parenting our son. I always heard how "typical" they thought he was too, and no matter how hard I tried I couldn't seem to express to them how very "atypical" he really was. It is so hard. You have so much wisdom and understanding, and although Slugger may not realize it yet, he is so lucky to have you.

Blogger Tereasa said...
Thank you, thank you, thank you!! You get it!!!!!

Anonymous Anonymous said...
And you and slugger are spectacularly perfect for each other...
You're a strong woman with a strong child. When I read about slugger begging for things, boy did it remind me of Sweetpea. In many many ways he faired better than his sister, but this was one area where all his stress/worries/anxieties/needs manifested.
Thinking of you both each and every day! Almost ready to send your parcel!
Kate
aspecialfamily

Blogger Ani said...
once again,your post moved me to tears. it is clear that you see your son for who he is - the good stuff and the issues, and you are working hard to provide him with the love, consistency, and help he needs.

thank you for your candor - you are one special woman, blessed to have such a special son.

Blogger 6blessings said...
Wow! You said it!

Upon voicing a concern, I have seen the faces and heard the voices, "Yeh, my kid is going through that stage right now too." It is very frustrating. I have tried to explain that I had 4 bio kids before these 2, I understand normal child behavior, I know the difference between a stage and something different.

Yes, their child lies, all children lie. But my child does it differently, for different reasons, with different patterns, way more because of his past.

You definitely understand. The bwins were only half the age of Slugger, so I know you are dealing with so much more! I get it a little bit, but not to the full extent that you do.

I admire you so much for taking on this challenge and loving unconditionally. You are amazing. I do think that as soon as he feels comfortable with staying with someone else for an hour or so, that you need to take time for yourself every once in a while. After several years of parenting, I understand the need and importance of taking time for yourself, no matter how small it is.

Keep up the good work! Give Slugger a hug from us!

Blogger Lauri said...
Thank You, Hell yes and Amen to all of that.... you hit the nail on the head


It is so hard to get people to grasp the intention behind those typical looking behaviors.

I often feel that I am banging my head on the wall trying to describe the behaviors that my daughter exhibits and those well meaning " It's typical" comments drive me up a wall.

Can't a Mom get some support over here... I am not looking for issues believe me... they are there.. clearly visible.


I can only imagine that with an older child that it gets even tricker and harder to navigate the waters of what is typical and what is manipulative.

Your doing a great job.... great insightful post

Blogger kaymommy said...
Maggie,

Thank you for your insight. As someone on the pre-adoptive side of older child adoption I really appreciate your openness and willingness to share your experiences as it gives me a peek into what I might encounter.

I have a friend locally (well, two hour drive - actually) who adopted an older child from the same children's home as we are adopting from. They visited here recently. I felt so inadequate to address her concerns about her daughter. I wanted to help, but I quickly realized that until I have experienced it - not just read about it - I won't be in a place to advise on PI issues. I just tried to encourage her in her efforts to get through it all.

My bio son (10 yrs old) has some issues of his own and his behaviors are somewhat like you explained. It is not usually directly about the behavior, but about some underlying problem that he can't articualte. He is a beautiful intricate puzzle himself, so on that point I can understand somewhat.

Please know that I am keeping you in prayer and I do hope that you find time (even if just in small portions) to take care of yourself.

Blogger Gawdess said...
I'm not going to say that all the behaviours are normal etc. etc.

I am so there...and have been for a full year with my two youngest children.

I can say though that it will probably get a bit easier as time goes by because you will get more used to each other and that helps a lot with the exhaustion.

No guarantees but I think that some of what is so exhausting is all the "newness" - at least it was for me.

That doesn't mean all the issues have gone away, not by a long shot, just that the daily routine becomes just that and that helps.

I get it.
Really I do.

Blogger kate said...
Sent you an e-mail. Hope it helps!

Blogger Elle said...
Thank you, thank you, thank you. Thank you for putting into words what those of us with PI or traumatized past children feel every day.

We cannot simply slide questionable behaviors under the rug and call them a stage. There is so much more.

Thank you.

Blogger Jenni said...
This is such an important post Margaret. I have often experienced the same frustration from people who say, "That's just typical kid behavior." It is so hard to make them understand that while the behavior may be typical, the reasons behind the behavior are not. Also, many times, the intensity of the behavior in a PI or post-foster care kid is much higher than that of a kid raised without a traumatic background.

Unfortunately, I do not know a lot of people who have adopted preschool age kids ("older" kids to many in the adoptive community), and the history we have on our kids is vague at best. So finding and understanding the reasons behind certain behaviors can be difficult.

However, after a year and a half, things are getting better. Slowly, but surely, day by day, the fear-based behaviors are becoming less and less frequent. With your level of understanding and the patience you have displayed so far, I can only imagine that Slugger's fear-based behaviors will begin to diminish as well. Seeing that kind of healing taking place, and truly appreciating just how far our kids have come makes the challenges of parenting all worth while.

Anonymous jessie s said...
What a great post, well said.

Anonymous Anonymous said...
I don't get it, but I do empathize with you as another mother. I can't claim to get it because I do not have a child with these prior issues.

I do want you to know, that as a friend, I would love to see you take a few moments for yourself, see if your sister or best, bestest friend can take Slugger for McDonalds, or to the park (no purchase necessary, as to not indulge those requests).

You see, Margaret, even though I'm not in your "exact" shoes, I'm a mom too and it was almost impossible for me to admit that I needed some "alone" time. did it mean that I was not a good mom?, that I did not love my child?...I questioned myself everyday about this, until one day, a great friend came over and said with great conviction...."get out, go away for one hour"....we will be here when you get back, and everyone will be just as you left us!

I did it and it was magical, I was so tired when this all occured, I thought I may crash the car on the way to the grocery store, which is where I went on my first "solo" outting....funny now to think of it, but at the time, it saved a small part of my sanity.

let us know if we can assist in ANY way, and I will not tell you that I get it, because I never could, but you have our thoughts and our shoulders to lean on, should that help out.

much love for you and Slugger, what an amazing family
the hartmans of wixom lake

xoxo

Blogger kris said...
Oh my god. You got me with the punch line woman. You got me. I'm crying my eyes out.

Thanks for being so open, so candid. You teach me so much. But I guess I said that already. :O)

Blogger Carrie said...
(((Hugs))) Sounds like an exhausting job. I haven't posted much here lately because I feel like I don't have any advice or experiences to draw on that would be helpful but I am always pulling for you. I know that you are the best parent this child could have and that no matter how difficult you will do everything in your power to help Slugger live up to his potential.

Blogger M- said...
M, great post about something that is so hard to put into words. When A came home, I didn't get it, though I figured it out pretty quickly. But I can honestly say, nobody else did. They thought I ran too tight a ship, that I should ease up on him and he'd get "better", that I was his problem. I took him to counselors, and then I stopped taking him, when it was obvious that he wasn't able to show his true colors for her, that it wasn't helping. What it did help was me, she got it, and told me I wasn't as crazy as everyone made me think I was....crazy as they thought I was. For the first year or two he was home, I tried my best to make sure people didn't see his true colors. We stayed fairly holed up when things were bad, and he could be an angel when they were good (or even when they were bad, but he had more of an audience than just me). Then about the 2 yr mark, I started letting him fail for others. Partly so he could see that everyone loved him, and could forgive his shortcomings. Partly for me...so people would see that it wasn't just me. And fail he did, he stole from my best friend, he drilled holes in a ladder for my mom, he did somethings that I won't type b/c he'd hate to see them in writing, but suffice it to say, they finally got it. They finally understood why I parented him the way I did...not b/c I want to, but because I have to. He couldn't function any other way. But, it did turn around, and I don't have to parent him like that anymore for the most part. I can give him some space, but when things start to turn (they never get back to what they were in the beginning) for the worse, I can tighten up a bit, and he straightens out again. He and I had a talk the other day about how when he lies to me, or does some other thing that is deceptive, that my brain goes back 2 years and it takes me a while to trust him again, its an unfortunate consequence of going through hell and back again with him. I will tell you that three of the families that I know of with big kids all seemed to have a similar epiphany to what we did. Last Sept, my grandma came to stay with us. She thinks he is great...he walks on water. If I look at him crossways, she gets angry at me. I told him while she was here that he needed to be on his best behavior....he didn't believe me. We were in the car going to a soccer game and A said something in a nasty voice to E. I told him to stop, and when we got out of the car, I asked him to go and apologize to Em. My gm went crazy (in a Starbucks no less) about how I needed to lighten up on him, and I was to strict, etc. I told her, that when he isn't nice that he needs to apologize, and that's all that was being done. She (is demented) and went ballistic, and I finally got her back in the car, while everyone else walked into the SB. After she was a bit calmer, I had him come over and apologize to her as well. She told him she loved him, but that I was too strict, and that as of right then, I was no longer part of her family that only he would be. Oh, how that broke his heart. He stood up for me, and tried to explain how he'd been told to behave and hadn't listened and that apologizing wasn't too strict. He told her that he needed me to strict because he really wanted to be good, but that he had a hard time making good choices (in his few moments of clarity, he could admit that).That day, the world seemed to turn for him, and the sun started shining on our family. He has been a different kid since then. I'm not sure if it was that he saw I'd walk away from my gm for him, or what, but he finally got it. Slugger will too, and life will get better. It is just a slow process. And it is hard, easily the hardest thing I've ever done in my life. I hope things get easier, and Slugger starts to trust, but that brick wall they build around themselves is reinforced with metal I think. If ever you want to email you're welcome to...megs7175@hotmail.com

Blogger fuzzandfuzzlet said...
I owe you a huge apology. I think I once compared Slugger to my soon to be 9 year old suggesting that maybe PART of his behavior is just older boy stuff.

I should know better. We adopted my DD at 17 months have she is still a challenge. We have dealt with attachment issues and PI issues ( tho she was adopted out of foster care... oddly she is more PI than a lot of kids I know that truly should be PI)

At any rate I long ago stopped venting about her because people would say "oh all little girls do that once or twice" etc etc. I learned to be tight lipped and yet I have said the same thing to you. I am truly sorry.

Yeah Slugger probably does things that a lot of 8,9,10... year old boys do. The fact is that you as his mother just KNOW when it is more than typical behavior.

I hope you continue to share you feelings. You are right, you are going to get more than your share of unhelpful remarks. But I honestly feel that from time to time you will get outstanding advice.

I can`t wait for next baseball season when we can share baseball stories. My son is an avid athlete and baseball is his "A" game. It is tons of fun being a baseball mom.

Are you considering any current sports for Slugger? Or are you going to wait for baseball season?

Blogger jessy said...
Maggie,

I'll will be the first to admit that what you are doing--adopting an older child as a single mom--is one of the bravest, selfless, amazing, acts of love I've ever heard of. I don't think I could ever do what you are doing.
BUT please don't discredit the rest of us as irrelevant or rump sitters. Adoptive parents of children with attachment issues, organic deficiencies, emotional trauma, past neglect (and you know the list goes on and on) go through hell no matter what the age the child is adopted at. I hear the stories of children adopted at nine from the worst of orphanages who "never had any problems" or the sixteen year old that had been "raped, beaten, and severely burned" who was adopted and graduated top in their class, and I want to beat my brains out. WHY CAN'T I FIX ONE STINKING YEAR??!! I have to come to the place (and I have to come to that place again and again), where I just accept that she was not one of the resilient ones and learn to make the best of life now--while always striving to gain more and more ground.
I know what you mean about "normal" not being normal at all. My four year old might run through the house (which he knows is off limits, but in his excitement has forgotten the rule) and knock a pitcher of tea over. Marina would hear me say, "Ya'll be careful of that tea," and even though it had never occured to her before to bother the tea, she would bide her time, either wait till she thought no one was watching and push it off or "accidently" trip and knock it over. Same amount of tea on my floor for both incidents. Same results, but I would feel and react differently because of the intent. I would deal more firmly with Marina than with Ian. When I did, well meaning friends/family would say, "You are too hard on her!" "But I'm sure it was an accident!" "All three year old are clumsy!" "My little girl spilt something ever day until she was seven!" I want to scream, NO, NO, NO, NO, you DON'T UNDERSTAND!!

Blogger Lionmom said...
I hear you and I get you!

Anonymous One Tired Mama said...
You say that Slugger is spectacular. By what I've read so far, it sounds like you are pretty spectacular too! I wish I had half the strength you do. I wish I had half of the knowledge and perceptive skill that you do.

Blogger Lauren said...
This is a great post. I know in the past I have probably said many of those well meaning phrases.

I have told Lauri many times that things Livi does are typical BUT that she as her mom would know if they should be considered typical or beyond based on the reasons/intensity of them. I feel strongly that only a childs mom really knows the most about her kid since she is the primary care giver. (or the dad if he is the primary care giver)

But I also know that there are tons of people out there that truly just want to be supportive but don't know that their comments are nails on a chalk board so please don't discount those people who may not get it but try to be there for you. I know not all comments are well meaning but look for the ones that have sincerity behind them even if they are off the mark.

This really was a great post.